Health System
Organizations
ABOUT US
SERVICES
FINANCE
Plans
Reports
LIBRARY
WOMEN'S HEALTH SURVEY
The following is an Executive Summary of the Survey results. For a complete report, please contact CHF at 937-328-8841 or through this website.
During the summer of 2006, the Community Hospital Health Services Foundation (CHF) conducted a follow-up to the 2005 Physician Study. The purpose of this written survey was to understand how women, age 12 and up, in the greater Springfield and Clark County area access health services, particularly reproductive health services, and to assess the level of awareness of the availability of services. It is hoped that information gathered from this survey will help healthcare providers plan for and improve women’s health services for all women, regardless of ability to pay.
The method used for gathering information was not a statistically validated sample. Instead the survey was distributed widely throughout the county in order to make it available to as many women as had an interest in completing the form. To this end, the survey was distributed through thirteen area churches, the Clark County Combined Health District, the Clark County Public Library, Graceworks Lutheran Services, Rocking Horse Center, Planned Parenthood, Project Woman, Springfield Surgery Center, and obstetrician/gynecologist offices. In addition, surveys were available at the Clark County Fair and on the CHF website from July 15 through September 15. This distribution was supported by local radio advertising on WKSW and WULM and a Your Turn column in the Springfield News-Sun directing women to locations where the survey could be obtained.
A total of 387 surveys were completed with nearly 10% of responses submitted electronically through an on-line survey instrument. The sample is large enough to be valid for our population size and was not significantly different from the demographic segmentation of the area as reported by the Census Bureau. The typical respondent from our sample has the following profile: a Springfield resident (78%), over age 36 (76%, with 50% over age 50), married (49.5%), without children under age 18 (54%), and employed full or part time (58%). Sixty-eight percent of respondents have annual household incomes of less than $50,000 and 65% have commercial insurance.
Responses to this eight-question survey are summarized below:
WHICH SPRINGFIELD LOCATIONS DO YOU USE FOR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE?
Sixty percent (60%) cited private physician, 28% cited Community Hospital and 15% cited Mercy Medical Center. Eight and one-half percent (8.5%) of respondents name Rocking Horse Center and 7% name Planned Parenthood. Seventeen percent (17%) say that they did not use reproductive health services in the last 2 years. Eight and one-half percent (8.5%) say that they use a provider outside of Springfield. Younger women are just as likely to have a private physician as older women; but older women are more likely to use a healthcare provider outside of Springfield. Only half of respondents with incomes less than $15,000 use private physicians as compared to 80% of high-income women.
WHICH SERVICES DO YOU BELIEVE ARE AVAILABLE IN CLARK COUNTY?
Respondents were given a checklist of services and asked to identify as many as they believed were available and to indicate where one might get this service.
| Table 17: Response by Healthcare Service Avaliability | |
| Healthcare Service | Checked |
| Pregnancy testing | 81.0% |
| Nurse midwife services | 48.3% |
| Sterilization (tubes tied) | 59.7% |
| Birth control, prescription or device | 79.8% |
| Emergency contraception (“morning after pill”) | 36.2% |
| Testing, treatment, and counseling for sexual transmitted diseases (STDs) | 69.7% |
| Testing, treatment, and counseling for HIV/AIDS | 64.2% |
| Screening for cancer (mammogram, breast exam, PAP test, etc.) | 77.4% |
| Family planning services | 59.0% |
| Rape treatment and counseling | 54.5% |
| Infertility testing and counseling | 36.1% |
| Medically indicated abortion when life of the mother is threatened or | |
| the fetus is not compatible with life | 29.2% |
| Specialized reproductive services such as in-vitro fertilization, | |
| donor insemination, genetic screening/counseling | 17.6% |
| Perimenopausal and menopausal care | 6.8% |
| Don’t know | 17.4% |
Women have several misconceptions about available services. Forty-eight percent (48%) believe that nurse midwife services are currently available in the county; in reality, as of the fall of 2006, there are two nurse practitioners who see gynecological patients but no nurse midwives are delivering babies. Emergency contraception and medically indicated abortions are available in the county; however, only 30% of respondents think so. Finally, although only 1/3 of respondents agree, infertility testing and counseling are available through private physicians. Perhaps, low response is reflective of the fact that after initial screening, most patients are referred out-of-county for treatment.
The statistics point out some opportunities. Since only 60% of respondents believe that women can get their tubes tied or can get family planning services, there seems to be a significant opportunity for reproductive health education and information. Fewer than 47% believe that menopause care is available. This may indicate an unmet need that can be addressed by local providers. We have extensive rape victim advocacy, coordinated evidence collection and rape care services in the county; however only 54% are aware of these services. Is this an opportunity for an educational campaign? Finally, 17% of women don’t know what reproductive services are available; it is the younger, more affluent and insured woman who is more likely to be aware of services. This data can help us target our health care messages.
Have you, or someone you know, gone out of the county for reproductive healthcare in the last two years? Twenty-six and one-half percent (26.5%) say “yes.” Compare this to the 8.5% who report in Question 1 that they, themselves, use an out-of-county provider. More affluent women, those with commercial insurance and those who live on the east and west ends of the county are more likely to go out-of-county for services. The most prevalent explanation for not seeking healthcare services in Clark County is that the service is not available in Clark County. The table below summarizes the reasons for out-migration.
| Table 56: Reason by Response | |
| Reason | Checked |
| Physician not affiliated with a Springfield hospital/facility | 18.1% |
| Insurance does not cover the Springfield physician or facility | 8.6% |
| Out-of-town provider location more convenient | 11.4% |
| Established relationship with out-of-town physician/facility/agency | |
| continued after moving to Clark County | 9.5% |
| Service not provided in Springfield/Clark County | 28.6% |
| Other | 23.8% |
The 32 “Other” written reasons for using healthcare providers beyond the Springfield/Clark County area may be summarized into the following themes, arranged in no particular order of frequency or preference.
* Better quality service provided in location outside of Clark County.
* Higher level of confidence in out-of-county provider.
* Lack of healthcare insurance.
* Military.
* Regular physician moved; replacement physician would not accept respondent as new patient.
* Second opinion.
HAVE YOU OR SOMEONE YOU KNOW HAD DIFFICULTY OBTAINING WOMEN'S HEALTH SERVICES BECAUSE OF NO INSURANCE, POOR INSURANCE, OR INABILITY TO PAY ?
Thirty-four and one-half percent (34.5%) said, “yes.” Variances in income, method of payment for healthcare and employment status did not significantly affect the responses. The most cited reason for difficulty obtaining service is lack of insurance. The sub-population most often cited for lacking healthcare is Hispanic women.
ARE YOU CONCERNED ABOUT THE AVAILABILITY IN SPRINGFIELD OF A FULL RANGE OF REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH SERVICES FOR ALL WOMEN? Sixty-two percent (62%) said, “yes.” New Carlisle residents in particular are concerned about the availability in Springfield of a full range of reproductive health care. WHAT WOMEN'S HEALTH OR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH SERVICE WOULD YOU LIKE TO HAVE IN SPRINGFIELD THAT IS NOT AVAILABLE NOW? Although 61% of respondents said, “none”, 92 women wrote suggestions for health care services they want to see provided in Springfield. The responses may be summarized as follows:
* Prenatal care and infertility, including in vitro (19)
* Unwanted pregnancy, including abortion and contraceptive services (18)
* Women’s health center (15)
* All services/general (11)
* Cancer, including screening, cervical, breast, etc. (8)
* Education and counseling (6)
* Midwives (2)
* Miscellaneous (13)
Miscellaneous suggestions include:
* Hair removal
* Hospital that does not follow Catholic teachings
* Improvement of existing services; e.g., follow-up, testing
* Lactation
* Menopause
* More gynecologists, not OB/GYN physicians
* Neurology
* Obesity/weight control
* Sexually transmitted diseases testing, awareness
* Spanish language service
* Sterilization reversal
* Subsidized prescriptions/medicine)
* Transportation options
WHICH WOMEN'S HEALTH OR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH SERVICE DO YOU NEED MORE INFORMATION ABOUT?
Less than 20% expressed a need for more information and identified the kind of information they wanted. Forty-four women wrote in responses as follows:
* All/general (7)
* Cancer, including breast, cervical, etc. (6)
* Prenatal care, including infertility (5)
* Unwanted pregnancy (5)
* Aging, including menopause (4)
* Referrals (4)
* Sex education (3)
* Osteoporosis (2)
* Adoption (2)
* Affordability (1)
* Confidence that nothing will change due to the merger (1)
* Heart disease (1)
* Mental health (1)
* Multiple sclerosis (1)
* Rape treatment, counseling (1)
* Sexually transmitted diseases (1)
* Sterilization reversal (1)
* Weight and nutrition (1)
MY GREATEST WOMEN'S HEALTH CARE CONCERN IS . . .
One hundred eighty-six (186) women wrote in one or more concerns. Responses in rank order are as follows:
* Cancer, including breast, cervical, mammography (33)
* Unwanted pregnancy, including abortion, sterilization, and contraception (12)
* Affordable and reliable insurance coverage/healthcare/prescription coverage (8)
* Heart disease and high blood pressure (7)
* All, including general healthcare (5)
* Aging, including menopause and osteoporosis (4)
* Mental health counseling, stress (4)
* Prenatal care and infertility (3)
* Obesity and nutrition (2)
* Communication between doctor and patient (1)
* Diabetes (1)
* Drug clinic (1)
* Lactation (1)
* Podiatry (1)
* Roman Catholic influence (1)
* Sexually transmitted diseases, HIV/AIDS (1)
* Vision coverage (1)
* Abuse (1)
There is a high level of correlation among the responses to the last three questions, which should helpful to health care professionals in identifying programs and services for expansion or enhancement as well as marketing strategies and educational opportunities to improve the health of the women of our region.

